For the oldest building story, start with Hanson's or Mathers downtown. Bellhop gives you a historic hotel without the speakeasy ritual. Redlight Redlight and Wally's carry the kind of local history that comes from staying put.
| Room | What survived | What the night asks from you |
|---|---|---|
| Hanson's Shoe Repair | The 1883 Hanson Building may be downtown's oldest surviving building. The former shoe shop had Orlando's first electric sign. | Get the daily password before you climb to the rooftop speakeasy. |
| Mathers and The Phoenix Jazz Club | The venue dates the Phoenix Building to 1864. Cocktails sit upstairs and the jazz room occupies the second floor. | Read the detailed dress code before treating this like a casual bar stop. |
| Bellhop | The cocktail and coffee bar sits in the historic Angebilt Hotel at Wall Street and Orange Avenue. | Choose a quiet corner instead of a louder downtown room. |
| Redlight Redlight | The beer bar began in 2005 and now fills a former 1950s air-conditioning repair warehouse. | Go for independent beer and a neighborhood room rather than a themed history lesson. |
| Wally's Bar & Liquors | The Mills Avenue dive has been open since the mid-1950s. Even the original owner's urn remains by the front door. | Accept that the wallpaper has more stories than anybody can verify. |
Historic does not mean the same kind of night
Hanson's and Mathers make entry part of the experience. Bellhop lets the building stay in the background. Redlight Redlight is a beer room with a long local run. Wally's is the place that feels least interested in explaining itself.
Venue histories and current details were checked September 19, 2026. Use the linked profile to confirm hours, events, passwords, and dress rules.